Skip to main content

Ecclesiastes 7:15 -What did Solomon just say?

Good morning fellow pilgrims,

Well here it is Sunday evening and I realized that I didn't finish posting this yesterday.  This passage got my interest because of the "overly righteous" and "overly wicked" statements. Hope you are encouraged by the process of working through similar passages.

Blessings

Jeff

This is one of those "what does he mean" passages.  Well it is pretty clear what Solomon is saying, but it does not seem to fit in with other scripture very well.  In the Law, God tells Israel to be holy because He is holy.  Doesn't seem that is possible to be "overly righteous" if the standard is God's righteousness.  Likewise, since Adam was judged after one transgression, what is "overly wicked"?  So we need discernment.

One commentator draws a parallel with 1Cor 15:32-33

What do I gain if, humanly speaking, I fought with beasts at Ephesus? If the dead are not raised, “Let us eat and drink, for tomorrow we die.” 33 Do not be deceived: “Bad company ruins good morals.”   Paul states the scoffer's objection to morals in 32.  The answer to the objection is v33.  In Ecclesiastes, v16 is the objection and v17 is the answer.

Vain life is life without considering God.  Purely human terms.

overly righteous is taken to be self-righteousness.  If the reason for being good is to gain long physical life, then being too harsh on the body may actually be harmful.  This is essentially v32.  If we are just going to die tomorrow, a healthy diet is of no use.

overly wicked - used to show the contrast with overly righteous.  To engage in riotous excess because you might die tomorrow is a good way to actually die tomorrow,  Solomon is not advocating for a little sin now and then.  He is advocating against going crazy in sin.

So one of the things to learn from passages like this is not to take any passage in isolation from other scripture.  Scripture does not contradict itself.  Scripture interprets scripture.  We would never take 1 Cor 15:32b as Paul's actual advice for life.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Revelation 22:3-5 Final and eternal restoration - Day 365

Dear saints in the Lord, Congratulations!  You made it.  We have been through much turmoil in the last year ('20-'21).  But God is faithful to His promises.  I trust that you have been blessed in your reading and have drawn closer to God.   Since we didn't get the blog up and running at the beginning of the challenge, I am going to go back and post entries to cover that first month or so.   Blessings, Jeff Nothing accursed in the city of God, the new Jerusalem.  The presence of sin will be gone.  I am working on memorizing Westminster Shorter Catechism and currently on question 82.  Is any man able perfectly to keep the commandments of God? No mere man since the fall is able in this life perfectly to keep the commandments of God but does daily break them in thought, word and deed. I think our passage today points to the truth of this question.  Do you notice how this answer is not exactly the same as the question. "Any man" bec...
Post a Comment
Read more

Malachi 2:10-12 Here we go again!! Day 363

Good afternoon friends, As we draw to the end of the Old Testament, we see that Judah has rebuilt the temple and the walls of Jerusalem, but they are following in the footsteps of faithless fathers and not in the footsteps of Abraham and ultimately God.  The exile was a low point, but now a new low is about to happen.  The prophetic voice has once again become warning and not encouraging. Faithful reading and preaching of the word is all that keeps us from losing our way.  May we be faithful in our generation. Blessings, Jeff I am sure I have mentioned this before, but it bears repeating.  The section summary, chapter and verse are not in the original language.  They are all rather modern inventions to help us.  For example, the section title here is "Judah profaned the Covenant".  That is OK as far as it goes, but which Covenant?  So let's take a look. Observations Starts with 3 questions but who is asking the questions and to whom are they addre...
Post a Comment
Read more

2 Chronicles 35:23-26 Lament for the last good king - Day 364

Good morning fellow exiles and pilgrims, One more day of devotions.  We are indeed exiles and pilgrims in this world as we look not to the things that are seen but to the things that are unseen.  The 20th anniversary of 9/11 attacks can serve as a reminder that this world is not our home. Blessings, Jeff The lamentations for Josiah written by Jeremiah.  However, the book of Lamentations does not include any reference to Josiah as they are focused on the fall of Jerusalem.  While these lost lamentations were "made the rule" there are only 4 more kings and none of them were good like Josiah and none died in Jerusalem.  The phrase "to this day" generally refers to the time of the author (post exile).  Taken together, it may be that these laments were for the last good king and during the exile the people were longing for the next good king. Zerubbabel in a way was the next good king as temple and Jerusalem were rebuilt. But Jesus truly was the next king and He...
Post a Comment
Read more